[Indeed! But that will be for another time, considering that he doesn't seem to be question it anymore, now that she's talking about a potential catalyst. After all, she's owned a lot of these items for a long long time and no convention practice has ever lead to this mess.

But as soon as she had these earrings, this happened.

So imagine her surprise when he tells her those earrings were his.]

What?! I bought them from an antique store.

[She holds them up, out towards him.]

Are they yours? You should have them back then...I mean, I believe you. If you're here.

[There is no reason to doubt him when he materialised RIGHT HERE. And thinking about it, as she holds them up...they look like they suit him.]